---
title: "North Hollywood DUI Crash: Why Prosecutors Charged Murder, Not Manslaughter"
description: "After a minivan hit food vendors outside the North Hollywood Metro station and killed three women, Los Angeles prosecutors filed three murder counts instead of vehicular manslaughter. Here is what those charges require, how the sentencing exposure adds up, and what happens next in court."
url: "https://www.thehfirm.com/blog/north-hollywood-dui-crash-murder-charges"
site: "H Law Group"
published: "2026-11-17T08:00:00Z"
---

# North Hollywood DUI Crash: Why Prosecutors Charged Murder, Not Manslaughter

After a minivan hit food vendors outside the North Hollywood Metro station and killed three women, Los Angeles prosecutors filed three murder counts instead of vehicular manslaughter. Here is what those charges require, how the sentencing exposure adds up, and what happens next in court.

Category: DUI Law

Author: Nima Haddadi -- California DUI and criminal defense lawyer

Just before 6 p.m. on Tuesday, November 10, a Toyota Sienna went over the barriers at Lankershim and Chandler boulevards and through a canopy sheltering food vendors outside the North Hollywood Metro station. Three women died at the scene. Two more were hospitalized, one in critical condition. The Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office has charged the 61-year-old driver with three counts of murder, one felony count of DUI causing injury and one felony count of driving with a 0.08% or higher blood alcohol level, [according to the DA's office](https://da.lacounty.gov/media/news/valley-village-man-charged-murder-suspected-dui-crash-killed-three-women-north-hollywood). News reports say prosecutors allege his BAC was more than three times the legal limit.

The charges are allegations. He has not been convicted of anything and is presumed innocent. This article doesn't weigh the evidence in his case. It explains why a fatal DUI crash can be filed as murder at all, what prosecutors have to prove to make that charge stick, and how a case like this moves through a Los Angeles courtroom.

## Murder vs. manslaughter: the charge turns on mental state

Most DUI crashes that kill someone are charged as gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated. That charge requires gross negligence, judged by what a reasonable person would have known. [Penal Code 191.5](https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=PEN&sectionNum=191.5) itself says it does not stop prosecutors from charging murder when the facts show implied malice.

Implied malice is a different, subjective test. The prosecution has to prove this particular driver knew that driving drunk endangered human life and chose to drive anyway. California courts have allowed that theory in DUI cases since the 1981 Supreme Court decision in People v. Watson, which is why these cases are called [Watson murders](/blog/watson-murder-california).

## Can it be murder without a prior DUI?

The public reporting on this case doesn't mention any prior DUI record. That's worth noting because many people assume a Watson murder charge requires one. It doesn't.

A prior conviction helps prosecutors because it usually comes with the Vehicle Code 23593 advisement, a documented courtroom warning that driving under the influence can lead to a murder charge if someone dies. Without that, prosecutors build implied malice from other evidence, such as:

- An extremely high BAC, which can support an argument that the driver knew how impaired they were
- Speed and driving pattern, including near-misses before the crash (prosecutors here allege unsafe speed)
- Where the crash happened, for example a crowded sidewalk at a transit station
- Warnings from friends or bartenders, prior arrests, DUI classes or victim impact panels

A first-offense murder case is harder for the prosecution, because a high BAC alone shows impairment, not what the driver was thinking. That gap is often where these cases are fought.

## Why three murder counts, and how "54 years to life" adds up

California charges one count of homicide for each person killed. Second-degree [murder](/penal-codes/penal-code-187-murder) carries 15 years to life under Penal Code 190(a), so three counts sentenced consecutively would be 45 years to life.

The DA's office puts the maximum exposure as charged at 54 years to life. The extra years would come from the felony DUI counts tied to the injured victims and any enhancements, which the public reporting does not break down. Maximum exposure is a ceiling. It is not a prediction of the sentence, and judges have discretion over whether some terms run concurrently.

## Murder vs. gross vehicular manslaughter at a glance

|  | Second-degree (Watson) murder | Gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Code section | Penal Code 187 | Penal Code 191.5(a) |
| Mental state | Implied malice: driver actually knew the danger to life | Gross negligence: a reasonable person would have known |
| Sentence per count | 15 years to life | 4, 6 or 10 years |
| Prior DUI required? | No | No |
| Strike under Three Strikes? | Yes | Yes |

Prosecutors sometimes file both and let a jury choose, or resolve a murder case as manslaughter later. Our page on [gross vehicular manslaughter while intoxicated](/penal-codes/pc-191-5-gross-vehicular-manslaughter-while-intoxicated) covers that charge in more detail.

## What happens next in court

The driver made a first court appearance on November 16, and his arraignment is set for December 16 (case 26VWCF02111). He remains in custody with bail set at $6.13 million. From here, a felony case in Los Angeles County generally follows the same [criminal case process](/california-criminal-case-process) as any other:

1. Arraignment, where the defendant hears the charges and enters a plea
2. Preliminary hearing, where a judge decides whether there's enough evidence to hold the defendant to answer on each count, including whether the murder counts survive
3. Pretrial motions, often focused on how blood was drawn and tested and on what mental-state evidence comes in
4. Plea negotiations or trial

The preliminary hearing matters more in Watson cases than in most. It's the first point where a judge tests whether the implied-malice evidence is strong enough for a murder charge, or whether the case looks more like manslaughter.

## How the 2027 DUI laws fit in

This crash came seven weeks after Governor Newsom signed four DUI bills. The one most connected to murder charges is [Braun's Law (SB 907)](/blog/brauns-law-2027-california-dui-plea-deals), which extends the Watson advisement to people who plead down from a DUI to a lesser offense such as a wet reckless. It doesn't change what murder is. It means more drivers will leave court with a documented warning on their record, which is the kind of evidence prosecutors use in later murder cases. Our overview of the [new California DUI laws for 2027](/new-california-dui-laws-2027) covers the rest of the package.

## Frequently asked questions

### Can you be charged with murder for a DUI crash in California?

Yes. If prosecutors can show implied malice, meaning the driver knew driving impaired endangered life and did it anyway, a fatal DUI crash can be charged as second-degree murder.

### Do you need a prior DUI to be charged with Watson murder?

No. A prior conviction and its advisement make the case easier to prove, but prosecutors can rely on other evidence, such as BAC level, speed and the circumstances of the crash.

### Why is there a separate murder count for each victim?

Each death is a separate homicide under California law, so each one is charged as its own count, and the sentences can run consecutively.

### Can a Watson murder charge be reduced to manslaughter?

It can happen. A judge may decline to hold a defendant to answer on murder after the preliminary hearing, a jury may convict on manslaughter instead, or the case may resolve by plea. It depends on the evidence in each case.

### What is the sentence for second-degree murder in California?

Fifteen years to life per count under Penal Code 190(a). If you or a family member is facing charges after a serious DUI crash, our [Los Angeles DUI lawyers](/dui-lawyers-los-angeles) can review the facts in a confidential consultation.

## About Nima Haddadi

Nima Haddadi is a leading California DUI and criminal defense attorney with deep expertise in handling complex cases. Known for strategic defense and courtroom strength, he is a trusted choice for clients facing DUI, felony, and misdemeanor charges.

---

## Contact H Law Group

- Phone: (888) 499-4948 (phones answered 24/7)
- Email: info@thehlawgroup.com
- Free consultation: https://www.thehfirm.com/free-consultation
- Contact form: https://www.thehfirm.com/contact-us

### Offices

- Los Angeles Branch: 714 W Olympic Blvd, Suite 803, Los Angeles, CA 90015 -- (213) 463-5888
- San Diego Branch: 600 W Broadway, Suite 700, San Diego, CA 92101 -- (619) 349-4484
- San Jose Branch: 333 W San Carlos St, San Jose, CA 95110 -- (408) 338-6889
- Orange County Branch: 2030 Main St, Suite 1300, Irvine, CA 92614 -- (949) 356-9818
- Riverside County Branch: 41593 Winchester Rd, Suite 200, Temecula, CA 92590 -- (951) 327-7161
- Santa Barbara Branch: 1117 State St, Santa Barbara, CA 93101 -- (888) 499-4948

### Disclaimer

This website provides general legal information only and does not create an attorney-client relationship. For legal advice about your specific situation, contact H Law Group directly.